Best Countertop Ice Makers 2025: Nugget & Portable Ice Machines
The best countertop ice maker for most people is the GE Profile Opal 2.0 XL for nugget ice lovers, or the Frigidaire EFIC189 for budget-friendly bullet ice. After testing 14 models over 8 weeks, these two stood out for ice quality, production speed, and long-term reliability.
Quick Answer: Which Ice Maker Should You Buy?
For nugget ice enthusiasts: The GE Profile Opal 2.0 XL ($399) produces authentic Sonic-style ice with WiFi control and a 1 gallon tank for all-day production.
For best value: The Frigidaire EFIC189 ($93.99) makes ice in 6 minutes and produces 26 lbs daily—perfect for everyday use.
For budget nugget ice: The EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker ($118.99) delivers soft, chewable ice at a fraction of the GE Opal price.
8 weeks of hands-on use
Depending on ice type
Options for every budget
TL;DR Summary
After testing 14 countertop ice makers, the GE Profile Opal 2.0 XL ($399) is our top pick for nugget ice lovers, while the Frigidaire EFIC189 ($93.99) offers the best value for bullet ice.
Key Takeaways:
- •14 ice makers tested across nugget, bullet, and portable categories
- •Nugget ice makers ($119-399) produce soft, chewable Sonic-style ice
- •Bullet ice makers ($94-110) offer best value for everyday use
- •First ice batch ready in 6-15 minutes depending on model
- •Daily production ranges from 26-44 lbs across tested models
Testing period: October - December 2025 | Last update: December 5, 2025 | Last price check: December 5, 2025
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This helps fund our testing at no extra cost to you. We tested all products ourselves and only recommend what we would use in our own homes.
Why You Can Trust Our Ice Maker Reviews
We spent 8 weeks testing 14 countertop ice makers in a real home kitchen—not a lab. Each machine ran for at least 50 hours of ice production. We measured first-batch timing with stopwatches, weighed daily output on kitchen scales, and used decibel meters to check noise levels.
Our testing included nugget ice makers from $300-$600 and bullet ice makers from $90-$150. We evaluated ice quality (shape, texture, chewability), production speed, noise levels, ease of cleaning, and build quality. We also checked WiFi connectivity where available and tested self-cleaning functions.
14
Models Tested
700+
Hours of Testing
8
Weeks Duration
4
Key Metrics
Nugget vs. Bullet Ice: Which Should You Choose?
Understanding the difference between ice types is crucial before you buy. Each type has distinct advantages depending on how you plan to use your ice.
Nugget Ice (Pebble/Sonic Ice)
- • Soft, chewable texture—like Sonic Drive-In
- • Absorbs drink flavor for better taste
- • Chills drinks faster than hard ice
- • Perfect for cocktails and smoothies
Price range: $300-$600
Bullet Ice (Standard)
- • Hard, slow-melting cylinder shape
- • Keeps drinks cold longer without diluting
- • Faster production (6 min first batch)
- • Most affordable option
Price range: $90-$200
Our recommendation: If you love the soft, chewable ice from Sonic or Chick-fil-A, invest in a nugget ice maker. If you primarily want cold drinks without quick dilution, a bullet ice maker is the smarter choice at half the price.
Our Top Ice Maker Picks for 2025
$399.00
$649.0039% off
GE Profile Opal 2.0 XL Nugget Ice Maker with 1 Gallon Tank
38 lbs
Daily Output
10 minutes
First Batch
52 dB
Noise Level
1 gallon tank (3x production capacity)
Water Capacity
Best for: Cocktail enthusiasts and families who love Sonic-style chewable ice
Skip if: You need budget-friendly ice or prefer hard ice cubes
Pros
- • Authentic chewable nugget ice identical to Sonic restaurants
- • 1 gallon tank triples production without refilling
- • WiFi & SmartHQ app with Alexa/Google voice control
Cons
- • Rating slightly lower than competitors at 3.7 stars
- • Slightly louder than bullet ice makers
- • Large footprint (17.5 x 13.43 x 16.5 inches)
Our Take: At $399 ($250 off regular price), this is the gold standard for nugget ice at home. The 1 gallon XL tank upgrade means all-day ice production without refills. Smart features alert you when ice is ready or water is low.
$93.99
$99.996% off
Frigidaire EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker, 26 lbs per Day
26 lbs
Daily Output
6 minutes
First Batch
45 dB
Noise Level
2.3 quarts
Water Capacity
Best for: Budget-conscious buyers who want reliable everyday ice
Skip if: You want nugget ice or need more than 26 lbs/day
Pros
- • Amazon Overall Pick with 16,700+ reviews
- • Best value at under $94
- • Fast first batch in just 6 minutes
Cons
- • Makes bullet ice only, not nugget
- • Smaller daily production (26 lbs)
- • No self-cleaning function
Our Take: At $93.99, this is the best value ice maker we tested. With 400+ bought in past month, it produces ice faster than machines twice its price. Perfect for apartments, RVs, and backup ice production.
$109.98
$109.98
Silonn Countertop Ice Maker, 9 Cubes Ready in 6 Mins, 26lbs in 24Hrs
26 lbs
Daily Output
6 minutes
First Batch
42 dB
Noise Level
2 quarts
Water Capacity
Best for: First-time buyers and those with limited counter space
Skip if: You need high-volume ice production or nugget ice
Pros
- • Amazon Overall Pick with 24,300+ reviews
- • 2K+ bought in past month - bestseller
- • Ultra-quiet operation at 42 dB
Cons
- • Basic bullet ice only
- • Smaller water reservoir
- • No WiFi or smart features
Our Take: At $109.98, this is the most popular ice maker on Amazon with 2K+ monthly purchases. The self-cleaning function at this price point is rare. Ideal for home kitchens, offices, and bars.
$118.99
$189.0037% off - Limited Time Deal
EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertop, Sonic Pebble Ice Machine 35lbs/24H
35 lbs
Daily Output
12 minutes
First Batch
50 dB
Noise Level
3 quarts
Water Capacity
Best for: Those who want affordable nugget ice without premium pricing
Skip if: You prefer proven brands or need WiFi connectivity
Pros
- • Amazon Overall Pick - 6K+ bought in past month
- • Best value nugget ice maker at $119
- • Self-cleaning function for easy maintenance
Cons
- • No WiFi connectivity
- • Slightly longer first batch time
- • Less established brand than GE
Our Take: At $118.99 (37% off), this is the best budget nugget ice maker. With 6K+ monthly purchases, it produces authentic soft ice at a fraction of GE Opal's price. Limited time deal makes it exceptional value.
$289.99
$329.0012% off
Newair Nugget Ice Maker Countertop, 44 lbs in 24 Hours, Black Stainless
44 lbs
Daily Output
15 minutes
First Batch
55 dB
Noise Level
3.5 quarts
Water Capacity
Best for: Heavy entertainers and large families needing maximum production
Skip if: You have limited counter space or want more reviews for confidence
Pros
- • Amazon Overall Pick designation
- • Highest daily production in our test (44 lbs)
- • Premium black stainless steel construction
Cons
- • Newer product with fewer reviews (45)
- • Louder operation at 55 dB
- • Longer first batch wait time
Our Take: At $289.99 (12% off), this is the best high-volume nugget ice maker. The 44 lb/day capacity means you will never run out of ice during parties or family gatherings.
$269.99
$269.99
WIE Nugget Ice Maker Countertop, 44 lbs in 24 Hours, 0.75 Gallon Tank
44 lbs
Daily Output
12 minutes
First Batch
50 dB
Noise Level
0.75 gallon
Water Capacity
Best for: Those wanting high-capacity nugget ice at mid-range price
Skip if: You want established brands or higher-rated options
Pros
- • High 44 lb daily production capacity
- • Large 0.75 gallon water tank
- • Self-cleaning function included
Cons
- • Lower rating at 3.4 stars
- • Limited reviews (59)
- • Less established brand
Our Take: At $269.99, this offers high-capacity nugget ice production. Best for buyers who prioritize ice volume over brand recognition. The 0.75 gallon tank reduces refill frequency.
$159.99
$159.99
COWSAR Nugget Ice Maker Countertop, Soft Chewable Crushed Ice, 34lbs/Day
34 lbs
Daily Output
10 minutes
First Batch
48 dB
Noise Level
3 quarts
Water Capacity
Best for: Budget nugget ice seekers who want reliable performance
Skip if: You want WiFi features or highest-rated options
Pros
- • Affordable nugget ice at $160
- • One-button simple operation
- • Self-cleaning function included
Cons
- • Moderate rating at 3.7 stars
- • No app connectivity
- • Basic design aesthetic
Our Take: At $159.99, this is among the most affordable nugget ice makers that produces genuinely good pebble ice. Great for those who want Sonic-style ice without breaking the bank.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Model | Ice Type | Daily Output | First Batch | Price | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GE Profile Opal 2.0 XL Nugget Ice Maker with 1 Gallon Tank | Nugget | 38 lbs | 10 minutes | $399.00 | 3.7 |
| Frigidaire EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker | Bullet | 26 lbs | 6 minutes | $93.99 | 4.3 |
| Silonn Countertop Ice Maker | Bullet | 26 lbs | 6 minutes | $109.98 | 4.3 |
| EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertop | Nugget | 35 lbs | 12 minutes | $118.99 | 4 |
| Newair Nugget Ice Maker Countertop | Nugget | 44 lbs | 15 minutes | $289.99 | 4 |
| WIE Nugget Ice Maker Countertop | Nugget | 44 lbs | 12 minutes | $269.99 | 3.4 |
| COWSAR Nugget Ice Maker Countertop | Nugget | 34 lbs | 10 minutes | $159.99 | 3.7 |
* Prices are subject to change. Last verified: December 5, 2025. Daily output based on manufacturer specs and our testing.
Complete Buyer's Guide: How to Choose an Ice Maker
1. Choose Your Ice Type
The most important decision is whether you want nugget (pebble) ice or bullet (standard) ice. Nugget ice costs more but delivers the soft, chewable texture that cocktail enthusiasts and ice chewers love. Bullet ice is affordable and practical for everyday use.
- • Nugget ice: Soft, chewable, absorbs flavors—$300-$600
- • Bullet ice: Hard, slow-melting, affordable—$90-$200
2. Consider Daily Production Needs
Match production capacity to your household size and usage patterns. A typical drink uses 8-12 oz of ice. Most families of 2-4 do well with 26-33 lbs/day. Heavy entertainers should consider 40+ lb/day models.
- • Light use (1-2 people): 26 lbs/day is sufficient
- • Medium use (3-4 people): 33-40 lbs/day recommended
- • Heavy use (5+ people or parties): 44+ lbs/day ideal
3. Check Noise Levels
If your ice maker will sit on the kitchen counter near living areas, noise matters. Bullet ice makers are generally quieter (40-45 dB) than nugget makers (48-55 dB). For reference, a refrigerator hums at about 40 dB.
- • Under 45 dB: Whisper quiet—ideal for open kitchens
- • 45-50 dB: Moderate—noticeable but not disruptive
- • Over 50 dB: Audible—best placed away from living areas
4. Evaluate Size and Features
Measure your counter space before buying. Most countertop ice makers range from 9x12 to 12x17 inches. Leave 4-6 inches clearance for ventilation. Consider features like self-cleaning, WiFi connectivity, and ice basket size.
- • Self-cleaning: Saves 30+ minutes of maintenance monthly
- • WiFi/App: Alerts when ice is ready or water is low
- • Side tank: Extends production time between refills
Budget Pick
$90-$150
Bullet ice, basic features, reliable performance
Mid-Range
$300-$450
Nugget ice, self-cleaning, higher capacity
Premium
$450-$600
WiFi, side tank, premium nugget ice
How to Get the Best Results from Your Ice Maker
Initial Setup
Place on a level surface with 4-6 inches clearance on all sides. If shipped in cold weather, let it sit at room temperature for 24 hours before first use. Fill with filtered water for best ice quality.
First Batches
Discard the first 2-3 batches of ice. This clears any manufacturing residue or dust from shipping. After that, your ice is ready to use and taste great.
Regular Cleaning
Clean every 2-4 weeks using the self-cleaning function or a vinegar solution (1:10 ratio with water). Wipe the exterior weekly. This prevents mineral buildup and keeps ice tasting fresh.
Optimize Water Quality
Use filtered or bottled water for clearer, better-tasting ice. Avoid distilled water as it can affect ice formation. Replace water filters every 3-6 months if your model has one.
Storage Tips
If not using for extended periods, drain all water, run a cleaning cycle, and leave the lid open to dry completely. Store in a cool, dry place to prevent mold or mildew growth.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best countertop ice maker for home use?
▼
How long does a countertop ice maker take to make ice?
▼
What is the difference between nugget ice and bullet ice?
▼
Do countertop ice makers need a water line?
▼
How much electricity does a countertop ice maker use?
▼
Can I leave my countertop ice maker on all the time?
▼
How do I clean a countertop ice maker?
▼
Why is my countertop ice maker not making ice?
▼
What size countertop ice maker do I need?
▼
Are nugget ice makers worth the higher price?
▼
How loud are countertop ice makers?
▼
Can I use filtered water in my ice maker?
▼
Final Recommendations
Still Not Sure?
If you are new to countertop ice makers and want to start with something affordable and reliable, go with the Frigidaire EFIC189. It has over 16,700 reviews, makes ice in 6 minutes, and costs under $94. You can always upgrade to a nugget ice maker later if you discover you want that soft, chewable ice.
Remember: All our picks are available on Amazon with free returns, so you can try them risk-free and return within 30 days if they do not meet your expectations.
Important Note: Purchases through our Amazon links support ongoing testing and content updates. Prices and availability are subject to change. We recommend checking current prices before purchasing.
Related Guides You Might Like
Compact Appliances for Small Apartments 2025
Space-saving appliances for studio and small kitchens
Top Kitchen Appliances 2025
Must-have coffee makers, air fryers, and more
Smart Hybrid Kitchen Appliances 2025
Space-saving, energy-smart picks for modern kitchens
Energy-Efficient Appliances That Cut Bills
Amazon picks to save money on utilities
Found This Guide Helpful?
Share it with friends who are looking for the perfect ice maker!
