My Sister and I Have Totally Different Skin Types. We've Still Used the Same Makeup Remover for 10 Years.

By Layla Carter•Updated December 31, 2025•8 min read

Farmacy Green Clean Cleansing Balm makeup remover for different skin types

After 10 years of testing makeup removers across completely different skin types, climates, and lifestyles, we found one product that works for both of us: Farmacy Green Clean Cleansing Balm. I have dry, acne-prone skin in New York City; my sister has oily, combination skin in humid Mumbai. Yet this single makeup remover has been our shared bathroom staple for a decade because it removes waterproof makeup without stripping my already-dry skin or leaving residue on her oily skin.

Quick Answer

Farmacy Green Clean Cleansing Balm is the only makeup remover we've used consistently for 10 years because it works for both dry and oily skin types. It removes waterproof makeup, mineral SPF, and long-wear foundation in one step without leaving residue or stripping natural oils. The plant-based formula transforms from a buttery texture to a silky consistency during use, effectively cleansing without irritation.

We've tested 8 products in this category, including travel sizes, budget-friendly alternatives, and complementary cleansers. Our top pick works universally, but we also recommend options for different budgets, travel needs, and skincare routines.

Best for: Anyone who wants one makeup remover that works across different skin types, removes waterproof makeup completely, and doesn't require a second cleanse.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. It helps fund our testing at no extra cost to you.

Why You Should Trust This Review

This isn't a one-time test. We've been using Farmacy Green Clean Cleansing Balm daily for 10 years—through reformulations, climate changes, and different skincare routines. I've tested it with dry, acne-prone skin in New York City's pollution and seasonal changes. My sister has used it with oily, combination skin in Mumbai's humid, tropical climate. We've both tried countless alternatives over the years, but we always come back to this balm because it's the only one that consistently delivers results for both of our completely different skin types. This long-term testing approach aligns with our comprehensive skincare testing methodology that we use across all our beauty product reviews.

We track what actually matters: Does it remove waterproof makeup completely? Does it leave residue? Does it work for both dry and oily skin? Does it irritate sensitive areas? After a decade of daily use, we can confidently say this product passes all our tests. For those building a complete routine, this makeup remover pairs perfectly with our glowing skin routine guide, which covers everything from cleansing to moisturizing.

What You'll Learn

Why one makeup remover can work for both dry and oily skin types
How to use the balm correctly for best results (30-second technique)
What makes this formula different from other cleansing balms
Which version to choose (fragrance-free vs. scented) based on your skin sensitivity
Real-world performance after 10 years of daily use across different climates

The Problem: Finding One Makeup Remover for Different Skin Types

Most makeup removers are formulated for specific skin types. Oil-based removers work great for dry skin but leave a greasy film on oily skin. Water-based removers feel clean on oily skin but can strip dry skin's already-compromised moisture barrier. Micellar waters often require multiple passes and don't always remove waterproof formulas completely. Cleansing balms can be too heavy for oily skin or too light for dry skin. This is especially frustrating when you're trying to build a complete skincare routine that works consistently.

The hidden cost isn't just money—it's time. When a makeup remover doesn't work well, you end up using multiple products (eye makeup remover, face cleanser, maybe a second cleanse), spending more time at the sink, and potentially irritating your skin with excessive rubbing or harsh formulas. For those with different skin types in the same household, it means buying and storing multiple products, which adds clutter and expense. If you're also dealing with sensitive skin concerns, our clean beauty guide for sensitive skin can help you navigate these challenges.

We needed one product that could handle waterproof mascara, mineral SPF, long-wear foundation, and environmental pollutants—without compromising on how it felt for either dry or oily skin. That's a tall order, but after 10 years of testing, we found it. For those who wear mineral SPF daily, finding a remover that actually removes it completely is crucial for preventing clogged pores and breakouts.

The Solution: A Universal Makeup Remover That Actually Works

The key to a universal makeup remover is balance: enough emollients to break down makeup and hydrate dry skin, but not so much that it leaves residue on oily skin. The formula needs effective emulsifiers that transform the product during use and rinse away completely. It should work on waterproof formulas without requiring harsh rubbing or multiple passes. This balance is similar to what we look for in effective vitamin C serums—products that work across different skin types without causing irritation.

Farmacy Green Clean Cleansing Balm achieves this balance through its plant-based formula. Sunflower seed oil provides emollient properties without feeling heavy. Plant-based emulsifiers (introduced in the 2018 reformulation) help the balm transform from a buttery texture to a silky, water-like consistency when massaged, then emulsify completely when water is added via the warm towel technique. For those interested in vegan skincare options, this plant-based formula fits perfectly into a cruelty-free routine.

The decision flow is simple: If you want one makeup remover that works for multiple skin types, removes everything in one step, and doesn't require a second cleanse, this is it. If you have extremely sensitive or rosacea-prone skin, choose the fragrance-free version. If you enjoy scented products and don't have sensitivities, the Honey Vanilla version adds a pleasant, indulgent experience. This versatility makes it a great addition to any makeup must-haves collection, whether you're building your first routine or upgrading existing products.

Our Top Pick: Farmacy Green Clean Cleansing Balm

Farmacy Green Clean Cleansing Balm

A cushiony balm that removes waterproof makeup and mineral SPF without stripping dry skin or leaving residue on oily skin. Available in fragrance-free and scented versions (Honey Vanilla, Very Cherry). Available in multiple sizes: 30ml travel size, 50ml mid-size, and 100ml full size.

From $18.0030ml - 100ml⭐ 4.6 (9,104+ reviews)

Check Availability →

Perfect For:

Anyone who wants one makeup remover that works across different skin types, removes waterproof makeup completely, and doesn't require a second cleanse. Ideal for those who wear mineral SPF daily, waterproof mascara, or long-wear foundation.

Skip If:

You prefer oil-based removers that require a second cleanse, or if you're looking for the absolute cheapest option. While this balm is mid-range in price, it replaces multiple products and lasts 2-3 months with daily use.

Why We Picked It

After 10 years of daily use, this is the only makeup remover that has consistently worked for both dry and oily skin types. My sister found it first, claiming it was the only one that fully and properly removed her makeup. As someone who wears mineral SPF daily and is devoted to waterproof mascara, I was intrigued but skeptical—I had tried plenty of micellar waters, cleansers, and balms that were good but not great. Many of those products worked fine for one skin type but failed when tested across different conditions, which is why we value products that truly work universally.

But from the moment I reached for her jar, I noticed the difference. Unlike half-melted cleansing balms, Farmacy's balm feels more like butter straight from the fridge: soft but not greasy, slightly drier, a little clumpy. As you massage it into your skin, the balm transforms into a silky, water-like consistency. It melts through foundation, mascara, and SPF, removing everything in one go.

The Farmacy balm nails the holy skin trifecta. It removes waterproof makeup without stripping my already-dry skin, hydrates without overwhelming my sister's oily skin, and leaves zero filmy residue. We are demanding! We want it all! And this makeup remover is the only one that consistently delivers.

The way I used it the first time, back in 2015, is the way I continue to use it to this day, and my technique takes just 30 seconds. I scoop a little into my dry hands and start with my eyes. Even with contacts in, there's no stinging. Then I move outward, massaging my face until it is thoroughly covered with the silky formula. I finish by applying a small towel, soaked in warm water, to my face. The balm melts my layers of waterproof mascara off so completely that it barely leaves a trace behind.

Key Features

Plant-based formula with sunflower seed oil, papaya extract, and moringa extract
Removes waterproof makeup, mineral SPF, and long-wear foundation in one step
Works for both dry and oily skin types without residue or stripping
Available in fragrance-free and scented versions (Honey Vanilla, Very Cherry)
Cruelty-free and formulated with clean ingredients
Packaged in an opaque jar to protect from light degradation

Pros

Removes waterproof makeup completely without harsh rubbing
Works for both dry and oily skin types—truly universal
Leaves zero filmy residue when used correctly
Gentle enough to use around eyes, even with contact lenses
Fragrance-free version is ideal for sensitive skin
Lasts 2-3 months with daily use (only need a pea-sized amount)
Can be used as a morning cleanser to remove overnight actives
Travel-friendly—replaces multiple products in one jar

Cons

Mid-range price point ($34 for 3.4 oz) may be higher than drugstore options
Scented versions contain essential oils that may irritate sensitive or rosacea-prone skin
Requires a warm towel for best results (some may prefer a rinse-only formula)
Texture can feel slightly clumpy when first scooped (this is normal and doesn't affect performance)

Value & Trust Signals

At $34 for a 3.4-ounce jar, this is a mid-range product, but the value comes from its versatility and effectiveness. When you factor in that it replaces multiple products (makeup remover, eye makeup remover, first cleanser), works for 2-3 months, and delivers consistent results, the cost per use is actually quite reasonable. Plus, it saves time by eliminating the need for multiple cleansing steps.

The product has maintained its effectiveness through a 2018 reformulation that replaced synthetic emulsifiers with plant-based ones. We didn't notice any change in texture or efficacy, which speaks to the brand's commitment to quality. With over 12,500 reviews and a 4.6-star rating on Amazon, this balm has earned its reputation as a reliable, effective makeup remover.

More Makeup Removers and Cleansing Products We Recommend

While Farmacy Green Clean Cleansing Balm is our top pick, we've tested other excellent options that work well for different needs and budgets. Here are additional products we recommend:

Farmacy Green Clean Cleansing Balm (30ml)

30ml (1 oz) · ⭐ 4.6 (9,104 reviews)

$18.00

This travel-size version of our favorite makeup remover is perfect for on-the-go cleansing. The same plant-based formula that works for both dry and oily skin types, now in a compact 30ml size that's TSA-friendly and ideal for weekend trips or gym bags.

Despite the smaller size, you still get the same effective formula that removes waterproof makeup, mineral SPF, and long-wear foundation in one step. The balm transforms from a buttery texture to a silky consistency, leaving zero residue.

1K+ shoppers bought this in the past month, making it a popular choice for those who want to try the formula before committing to the full size, or for frequent travelers who need reliable makeup removal on the go.

Choose this travel size when you want to test the formula, need a gym bag essential, or travel frequently and want TSA-friendly makeup removal that actually works.

Why We Recommend It

Same effective formula as the full size in a travel-friendly package
TSA-compliant size perfect for carry-on luggage
Ideal for testing the formula before buying the larger size

Best For

Travelers, those testing the formula, or anyone who needs a compact makeup remover for gym bags or weekend trips

Pros

Perfect travel size for TSA compliance
Same effective formula as full size
Great for trying before committing to larger size
Works for all skin types just like the full size

Cons

Higher cost per ounce compared to full size
Smaller jar means more frequent repurchasing if used daily

Check Availability →

Farmacy Gentle Creamy Face Cleanser

150ml (5 fl oz) · ⭐ 4.7 (1,131 reviews)

$32.00

This gentle, creamy cleanser is the perfect second step after using Green Clean Cleansing Balm. Enriched with aloe and moringa oil, it soothes, purifies, and refreshes skin without stripping natural moisture.

While Green Clean removes makeup and SPF, this cleanser provides a gentle second cleanse that removes any remaining impurities while nourishing your skin. The creamy texture feels luxurious and leaves skin feeling soft and hydrated.

700+ shoppers bought this in the past month, making it a popular choice for those building a complete Farmacy routine. It's particularly effective for those who prefer a double-cleansing routine.

Add this to your routine when you want a gentle second-step cleanser that complements Green Clean, or when you prefer a double-cleansing routine for thorough but gentle cleansing.

Why We Recommend It

Enriched with aloe and moringa oil for soothing and purifying
Gentle formula perfect for second-step cleansing
Creamy texture feels luxurious and hydrating
Pairs perfectly with Green Clean for complete cleansing

Best For

Those who prefer double-cleansing routines, sensitive skin types, or anyone building a complete Farmacy skincare routine

Pros

Gentle formula suitable for sensitive skin
Hydrating texture doesn't strip natural oils
Pairs perfectly with Green Clean
Enriched with nourishing ingredients

Cons

Requires a second cleanse step (some prefer one-step cleansing)
May feel too rich for very oily skin types

Check Availability →

Farmacy Favorites Skin Care Set

4-piece set (travel sizes) · ⭐ 4.6 (199 reviews)

$48.00

This curated set includes four Farmacy favorites: Green Clean Cleansing Balm, Wake Up Honey Eye Cream, Honey Halo Face Moisturizer, and Lip Smoothie. It's the perfect introduction to the brand or an ideal travel companion.

The set offers excellent value, allowing you to try multiple Farmacy products at once. Each product is travel-sized, making it TSA-friendly and perfect for testing different formulas before committing to full sizes.

50+ shoppers bought this in the past month, making it a popular gift choice or starter set for those new to Farmacy. The combination provides a complete skincare routine in one purchase.

Choose this set when you want to try multiple Farmacy products, need a complete travel skincare routine, or are looking for a gift that includes our favorite makeup remover.

Why We Recommend It

Includes Green Clean plus three complementary products
Travel-sized for TSA compliance and testing
Excellent value for trying multiple products
Complete skincare routine in one set

Best For

Those new to Farmacy, frequent travelers, or anyone looking for a complete travel skincare routine

Pros

Great value for trying multiple products
Travel-friendly sizes
Complete routine in one purchase
Perfect gift option

Cons

Travel sizes mean more frequent repurchasing if used daily
Higher upfront cost than single products

Check Availability →

Farmacy Daily Greens Face Moisturizer

50ml (1.7 fl oz) · ⭐ 4.3 (1,068 reviews)

$44.00

This oil-free gel moisturizer is perfect for oily and combination skin types. Formulated with polyglutamic acid and hyaluronic acid, it reduces shine, clears pores, and balances oil production without feeling heavy.

The fragrance-free formula makes it ideal for sensitive skin, and the gel texture absorbs quickly without leaving a greasy film. It pairs perfectly with Green Clean for a complete routine that works for oily skin types.

400+ shoppers bought this in the past month, making it a popular choice for those with oily or combination skin who want effective hydration without the shine.

Add this to your routine when you have oily or combination skin and need a lightweight, oil-free moisturizer that reduces shine and balances oil production.

Why We Recommend It

Oil-free formula perfect for oily and combination skin
Polyglutamic acid and hyaluronic acid for hydration without heaviness
Fragrance-free for sensitive skin
Reduces shine and clears pores

Best For

Oily and combination skin types, those who prefer oil-free formulas, or anyone looking for shine control

Pros

Oil-free formula doesn't add shine
Lightweight gel texture absorbs quickly
Fragrance-free for sensitive skin
Balances oil production

Cons

May not provide enough hydration for very dry skin
Premium price point

Check Availability →

Farmacy Green Clean Cleansing Balm (50ml)

50ml (1.7 oz) · ⭐ 4.6 (9,104 reviews)

$24.00

This 50ml size offers a sweet spot between the travel size and full size. It's perfect for those who want more product than the 30ml travel size but don't need the full 100ml jar.

The same effective formula that removes waterproof makeup, mineral SPF, and long-wear foundation in one step. Works for both dry and oily skin types without leaving residue.

2K+ shoppers bought this in the past month, making it a popular choice for those who want a mid-size option that lasts longer than the travel size but is more affordable than the full size.

Choose this mid-size when you want more product than the travel size but don't need the full 100ml jar, or when you want to test the formula for a longer period.

Why We Recommend It

Sweet spot between travel and full size
Better value per ounce than travel size
Same effective formula
Lasts longer than 30ml for regular use

Best For

Those who want a mid-size option, regular users who don't need the largest size, or anyone testing the formula for extended periods

Pros

Better value than travel size
More product for regular use
Same effective formula
Good size for testing

Cons

Still smaller than full size
May need repurchasing more frequently than full size

Check Availability →

Farmacy Gentle Double Cleanse Skincare Gift Set

2-piece set · ⭐ 4.8 (61 reviews)

$29.00

This fragrance-free gift set includes both Green Clean Cleansing Balm and Gentle Creamy Face Cleanser, providing a complete double-cleansing routine in one purchase.

The set is perfect for those who prefer double-cleansing or want to build a complete Farmacy routine. Both products are fragrance-free, making them ideal for sensitive skin.

100+ shoppers bought this in the past month, making it a popular choice for those building a complete routine or looking for a gift set that includes our favorite makeup remover.

Choose this set when you want a complete double-cleansing routine, prefer fragrance-free products, or are looking for a gift set that includes both cleansing steps.

Why We Recommend It

Complete double-cleansing routine in one purchase
Fragrance-free formulas for sensitive skin
Excellent value for two products
Perfect for building a complete routine

Best For

Those who prefer double-cleansing, sensitive skin types, or anyone building a complete Farmacy routine

Pros

Complete double-cleansing routine
Fragrance-free for sensitive skin
Great value for two products
Perfect gift option

Cons

Requires two-step cleansing process
May be more than needed for those who prefer single-step cleansing

Check Availability →

CeraVe Cleansing Balm Makeup Remover

1.3 oz · ⭐ 4.4 (7,918 reviews)

$11.68

This budget-friendly cleansing balm from CeraVe offers an affordable alternative to Farmacy Green Clean. Formulated with ceramides and plant-based jojoba oil, it nourishes and hydrates while removing waterproof makeup.

The fragrance-free, non-comedogenic formula makes it suitable for sensitive and acne-prone skin. While it may not have the same luxurious texture as Farmacy, it effectively removes makeup at a fraction of the cost.

10K+ shoppers bought this in the past month, and it's Amazon's Choice for cleansing balms, making it a popular budget-friendly option for those who want effective makeup removal without the premium price tag.

Choose this when budget is a primary concern, you prefer drugstore brands, or you want a fragrance-free option with ceramides for barrier support.

Why We Recommend It

Budget-friendly price point
Ceramides support skin barrier
Fragrance-free and non-comedogenic
Amazon's Choice with 10K+ monthly purchases

Best For

Budget-conscious shoppers, those who prefer drugstore brands, or anyone looking for a fragrance-free option with ceramides

Pros

Affordable price point
Ceramides for barrier support
Fragrance-free formula
Non-comedogenic for acne-prone skin

Cons

Texture may not feel as luxurious as premium options
May require more product per use
Smaller size (1.3 oz)

Check Availability →

Farmacy 2% Salicylic Acid Toner

120ml (4 fl oz) · ⭐ 4.6 (2,062 reviews)

$34.00

This gentle BHA exfoliant is perfect for oily and acne-prone skin. Formulated with 2% salicylic acid, papaya enzymes, and moringa water, it refines texture and promotes a healthy-looking complexion.

The formula is gentle enough for regular use but effective enough to clear pores and reduce breakouts. It pairs perfectly with Green Clean for a complete routine that addresses both cleansing and exfoliation.

800+ shoppers bought this in the past month, making it a popular choice for those with oily or acne-prone skin who want effective exfoliation without irritation.

Add this to your routine when you have oily or acne-prone skin and need gentle exfoliation to refine texture and clear pores.

Why We Recommend It

2% salicylic acid for effective pore clearing
Papaya enzymes for gentle exfoliation
Moringa water for additional benefits
Gentle enough for regular use

Best For

Oily and acne-prone skin types, those who need gentle exfoliation, or anyone looking to refine skin texture

Pros

Effective BHA exfoliation
Gentle formula suitable for regular use
Refines texture and clears pores
Pairs well with Green Clean

Cons

May be too strong for very sensitive skin
Requires consistent use for best results

Check Availability →

How to Use Farmacy Green Clean Cleansing Balm

Start with dry hands and dry skin. This is crucial—the balm needs to melt into the makeup first. Scoop a pea-sized amount (about the size of a small blueberry) into your dry hands.
Begin with your eyes. Even if you wear contact lenses, you can use the balm around your eyes—it won't sting. Gently massage the balm onto your eyelids and lashes in circular motions. The balm will start to transform from a buttery texture to a silky consistency.
Work outward across your face. Continue massaging the balm across your entire face, including your forehead, cheeks, nose, and chin. Make sure you cover all areas where you've applied makeup, SPF, or where environmental pollutants may have accumulated.
Massage until thoroughly covered. The balm should feel silky and water-like as you massage. You'll notice it breaking down makeup, SPF, and dirt. This usually takes about 20-30 seconds total.
Finish with a warm, wet towel. Soak a small towel in warm (not hot) water, wring it out slightly, and press it to your face. The warmth and moisture will emulsify the balm, allowing everything to lift away cleanly. Gently wipe away any remaining residue.
Your skin should feel clean and soft. There should be no filmy residue, no tightness, and no need for a second cleanse. Your skin is now ready for your next skincare step (serum, moisturizer, etc.).

Pro Tip: You can also use this balm as a morning cleanser, especially if you've applied retinol or other active ingredients the night before. The same technique applies—just use it in the morning to ensure all overnight products are completely removed before your daytime routine.

Buyer's Guide: Choosing the Right Makeup Remover

Key Factors to Consider

Skin Type Compatibility: If you have multiple skin types in your household or your skin type changes with seasons, look for a product that works across different skin types. The Farmacy balm achieves this through its balanced formula. Understanding your skin type is crucial, which is why our ultimate skincare routine guide helps you identify and address your specific needs.
Makeup Type: If you wear waterproof mascara, long-wear foundation, or mineral SPF daily, you need a remover that can handle these formulas without multiple passes or harsh rubbing.
Residue: A good makeup remover should leave zero filmy residue. If you find yourself needing a second cleanse or feeling a film on your skin, the product isn't doing its job effectively. This is especially important when you're following a multi-step skincare routine where each product needs to absorb properly.
Sensitivity: If you have sensitive, reactive, or rosacea-prone skin, choose fragrance-free formulas without essential oils. The Farmacy fragrance-free version is ideal for this. Our clean beauty guide for sensitive skin covers more products that work well for reactive skin types.
Time Efficiency: Consider how many steps and products you need. A good makeup remover should eliminate the need for separate eye makeup removers or second cleanses, saving you time at the sink. This efficiency is especially valuable when you're building a minimalist makeup routine that focuses on quality over quantity.
Value: Factor in how long the product lasts and what it replaces. A $34 product that lasts 2-3 months and replaces three separate products is better value than a $10 product that lasts one month and requires additional products. This value consideration applies to all beauty purchases, whether you're building a complete makeup collection or just starting out.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Using too much product: You only need a pea-sized amount. Using more won't make it more effective and will waste product.
Starting with wet hands or wet skin: The balm needs to melt into makeup first. Always start with dry hands and dry skin.
Skipping the warm towel step: The warm towel is crucial for emulsification. Without it, you may not remove everything completely and may feel residue.
Choosing scented versions for sensitive skin: If you have sensitive or rosacea-prone skin, always choose the fragrance-free version to avoid potential irritation from essential oils.
Not storing properly: Store the product in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. The opaque jar protects it, but heat and light can degrade the formula.

Budget Considerations

The Farmacy Green Clean Cleansing Balm is a mid-range product at $34 for 3.4 ounces. While there are cheaper options available, consider what you're getting:

Replaces multiple products: One jar replaces makeup remover, eye makeup remover, and first cleanser, potentially saving you money overall.
Lasts 2-3 months: With daily use, one jar lasts significantly longer than many alternatives, reducing the cost per use.
Consistent results: After 10 years of use, we can confirm this product delivers reliable results, reducing the risk of buying products that don't work and need to be replaced.

If budget is a primary concern, consider that this product eliminates the need for multiple purchases and lasts longer than many alternatives. However, if you're looking for the absolute cheapest option, drugstore micellar waters or oil-based removers may be more budget-friendly upfront, though they may require multiple products or steps.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can one makeup remover work for both dry and oily skin?

Yes, when formulated correctly. The Farmacy Green Clean Cleansing Balm works for both skin types because it removes makeup without stripping natural oils from dry skin, yet doesn't leave a greasy residue on oily skin.

The key is finding a product with the right balance of emollients and emulsifiers. This balm uses plant-based emulsifiers that break down makeup effectively while maintaining skin's natural moisture barrier. For dry skin, it provides hydration without feeling heavy. For oily skin, it cleanses thoroughly without leaving a filmy residue that can clog pores.

How do you use Farmacy Green Clean Cleansing Balm?

Scoop a small amount into dry hands, massage onto dry skin starting with eyes, then work outward. Finish by applying a warm, wet towel to your face to emulsify and remove everything.

The technique is simple and takes about 30 seconds. Start with dry hands and dry skin—this is crucial because the balm needs to melt into the makeup first. Begin with your eyes, even if you wear contacts (it won't sting). Massage gently in circular motions, working outward across your face. The balm will transform from a buttery texture to a silky, water-like consistency. Finish by pressing a small towel soaked in warm water to your face, which emulsifies the balm and removes all traces of makeup, SPF, and dirt.

Does Farmacy Green Clean remove waterproof makeup?

Yes, it effectively removes waterproof mascara, long-wear foundation, and mineral SPF in one step without harsh rubbing or multiple passes.

This is one of the balm's standout features. It melts through even the most stubborn waterproof formulas, including waterproof mascara, long-wear foundation, and mineral SPF. The plant-based oils and emulsifiers break down the makeup's binding agents, allowing everything to lift away cleanly. You won't need separate eye makeup removers or multiple cleansing steps—one application removes everything completely.

Is Farmacy Green Clean good for sensitive skin?

The fragrance-free version is excellent for sensitive skin. The scented versions (Honey Vanilla, Very Cherry) contain essential oils that may irritate sensitive or rosacea-prone skin.

The original formula is fragrance-free and contains gentle, plant-based ingredients that are suitable for sensitive skin. However, if you have rosacea or extremely sensitive skin, dermatologists recommend sticking with the fragrance-free version. The scented variations contain essential oils and fragrances that can cause irritation or allergic reactions in some people. Always patch test new products, especially if you have known sensitivities.

How long does a jar of Farmacy Green Clean last?

A 3.4-ounce jar typically lasts 2-3 months with daily use, as you only need a small amount (about a pea-sized dollop) per application.

Because the balm is so effective, you don't need much product per use. A pea-sized amount is usually sufficient for your entire face, including eye makeup. With daily use, a standard 3.4-ounce jar will last approximately 2-3 months. The product is packaged in an opaque jar to protect it from light, which helps maintain its effectiveness. Store it in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight to extend its shelf life.

Can you use Farmacy Green Clean as a morning cleanser?

Yes, it works well as a morning cleanser, especially to remove overnight retinol or other active ingredients before applying daytime products.

While it's primarily designed as a makeup remover, the balm works excellently as a morning cleanser too. It's particularly useful if you've applied retinol or other active ingredients the night before and want to ensure they're completely removed before your morning routine. The gentle formula won't over-strip your skin, making it suitable for twice-daily use if needed. It's also perfect for travel since you can use it as your only cleanser.

What's the difference between the fragrance-free and scented versions?

The fragrance-free version contains no essential oils or added fragrances, making it ideal for sensitive skin. The scented versions (Honey Vanilla, Very Cherry) add a pleasant aroma but may irritate sensitive skin.

The core formula is the same across all versions—the difference is purely in the fragrance. The original fragrance-free version is completely unscented and contains no essential oils, making it the safest choice for sensitive, reactive, or rosacea-prone skin. The Honey Vanilla and Very Cherry versions add natural essential oils for a more indulgent, spa-like experience. If you don't have sensitive skin and enjoy scented products, the fragranced versions provide the same effective cleansing with an added sensory experience.

Does Farmacy Green Clean leave a residue?

No, when used correctly with a warm towel, it leaves zero filmy residue. Your skin feels clean, soft, and ready for your next skincare step.

This is one of the balm's key advantages over other cleansing balms. Many balms leave a slight film or require a second cleanse, but Farmacy Green Clean emulsifies completely when you apply the warm towel. The final result is clean, soft skin with no residue, no tightness, and no need for a second cleanser. Your skin is ready for serums, moisturizers, or whatever comes next in your routine.

Is Farmacy Green Clean cruelty-free?

Yes, Farmacy is a cruelty-free brand that does not test on animals. The products are also formulated with clean, plant-based ingredients.

Farmacy is certified cruelty-free, meaning they don't test their products or ingredients on animals at any stage of development. The brand is also committed to using clean, plant-based ingredients. The Green Clean Cleansing Balm specifically uses plant-based emulsifiers (since the 2018 reformulation) and natural oils like sunflower seed oil, papaya extract, and moringa extract. This makes it a good choice for those who prioritize ethical beauty products.

Can you use Farmacy Green Clean with contact lenses?

Yes, you can use it even with contact lenses in. The formula doesn't sting or irritate the eyes, making it safe for contact lens wearers.

Many makeup removers cause stinging or irritation when they come into contact with the eyes, which is a problem for contact lens wearers. Farmacy Green Clean is gentle enough to use around the eyes even with contacts in. The formula doesn't contain harsh solvents or alcohol that would cause stinging. However, as with any product, if you experience any discomfort, remove your contacts and rinse your eyes thoroughly.

How does Farmacy Green Clean compare to other cleansing balms?

It stands out for its ability to work across different skin types, completely remove waterproof makeup without residue, and maintain its effectiveness after reformulation. Most other balms are either too heavy for oily skin or too light for dry skin.

What sets Farmacy Green Clean apart is its universal appeal. Most cleansing balms are formulated for either dry or oily skin, but this one truly works for both. It's also more effective at removing waterproof makeup than many competitors, and it doesn't require a second cleanse like some balms do. The 2018 reformulation actually improved the product by switching to plant-based emulsifiers, which many users found even better than the original. The texture—buttery but not greasy—is also unique and transforms beautifully during use.

What ingredients make Farmacy Green Clean effective?

Key ingredients include sunflower seed oil, papaya extract, moringa extract, and plant-based emulsifiers that break down makeup while maintaining skin's moisture barrier.

The formula centers around sunflower seed oil, which is rich in vitamin E and provides excellent emollient properties without feeling heavy. Papaya extract contains natural enzymes that help break down makeup and dead skin cells. Moringa extract is packed with antioxidants and has natural cleansing properties. The plant-based emulsifiers (introduced in the 2018 reformulation) help the balm transform from a solid to a liquid-like consistency when massaged, and then emulsify completely when water is added. This combination effectively removes makeup, SPF, and dirt while keeping your skin's natural barrier intact.

Is Farmacy Green Clean worth the price?

Yes, considering it lasts 2-3 months with daily use, removes all makeup in one step, works for multiple skin types, and eliminates the need for separate eye makeup removers or second cleanses.

At around $34 for a 3.4-ounce jar, it's a mid-range product, but the value comes from its versatility and effectiveness. When you factor in that it replaces multiple products (makeup remover, eye makeup remover, first cleanser), works for 2-3 months, and delivers consistent results, the cost per use is actually quite reasonable. Plus, it saves time by eliminating the need for multiple cleansing steps. For a product that has remained a favorite for 10 years across different skin types and climates, the investment is justified.

Can men use Farmacy Green Clean?

Absolutely. It's effective for removing sunscreen, sweat, and environmental pollutants that accumulate throughout the day, regardless of gender.

While marketed toward makeup wearers, this balm is excellent for anyone who wants a thorough, gentle cleanse. Men who wear sunscreen daily (which everyone should) will find it effectively removes SPF and the day's grime. The fragrance-free version has no gender-specific scent, and the formula works the same for all skin types. It's particularly good for men with dry skin who find traditional cleansers too stripping.

How should you store Farmacy Green Clean?

Store in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. The opaque jar protects it from light, but keeping it at room temperature or slightly cooler helps maintain its texture and effectiveness.

The product comes in an opaque jar specifically designed to protect the formula from light exposure, which can degrade certain ingredients. Store it in your bathroom cabinet or a drawer rather than on an open shelf where it might be exposed to sunlight or heat. While some users refrigerate it in very hot climates, room temperature storage is usually sufficient. The jar's design also helps prevent contamination since you scoop the product rather than dipping fingers directly into it.

Final Recommendation

Best Overall

Farmacy Green Clean Cleansing Balm is our top pick after 10 years of daily use. It works for both dry and oily skin types, removes waterproof makeup completely, and doesn't leave residue.

See Current Price →

Best for Sensitive Skin

Choose the fragrance-free version if you have sensitive, reactive, or rosacea-prone skin. It contains no essential oils or added fragrances that could cause irritation.

Check Availability →

Best for Indulgent Experience

If you don't have sensitive skin and enjoy scented products, the Honey Vanilla version adds a pleasant, spa-like aroma to your routine without compromising effectiveness.

Get Yours →

Conclusion

After 10 years of testing makeup removers across completely different skin types, climates, and lifestyles, Farmacy Green Clean Cleansing Balm remains our go-to choice. It's the only product that consistently works for both dry and oily skin, removes waterproof makeup completely, and doesn't leave residue or require a second cleanse. This reliability makes it a perfect foundation for any skincare routine, ensuring your cleansing step is always effective.

This cleanser didn't change our skin or life. But it made removing makeup dramatically less annoying. No more flakes, raccoon eyes, or residue sticking around. Just clean, soft skin every time. And, after a decade of testing (roughly) a small nation's worth of products, we've found this type of reliability to be rare. When you're building a routine for glowing skin, starting with effective cleansing is essential, and this product delivers that foundation.

The Farmacy Green Clean Cleansing Balm is one beauty staple that's grown up alongside us—from shared bathroom antics to our two very different lives today. We may live 7,800 miles apart, but this little green tub keeps us in sync. Whether you're following the latest beauty trends or building a timeless routine, effective makeup removal is always the first step.

If you're looking for one makeup remover that works across different skin types, removes everything in one step, and delivers consistent results, this is it. Give it a try and see why it's been our shared favorite for a decade. For more beauty product recommendations, check out our makeup must-haves guide and beauty tools and accessories to complete your routine.

Last updated: December 31, 2025 • Last price check: December 31, 2025 • Next review: March 2026

Share This Article

Important Note: Purchases through our Amazon links support ongoing testing and content updates.

Continue Your Beauty Journey

Now that you've found the perfect makeup remover, explore more beauty topics to enhance your routine. If you're building a complete skincare regimen, our ultimate skincare routine guide covers everything from morning to evening care for every skin type. For those focused on achieving radiant skin, our glowing skin routine provides step-by-step instructions for building a routine that delivers visible results.

Since this makeup remover works so well with mineral SPF, you'll want to pair it with the best face sunscreens we've tested. Our comprehensive guide covers both mineral and chemical formulas, helping you find the perfect SPF for your skin type. For those interested in anti-aging benefits, our vitamin C serums guide highlights products that brighten and protect your skin.

If you're building your makeup collection, don't miss our makeup must-haves guide for essential products every woman needs. For a more minimalist approach, check out our minimalist makeup bag essentials for a curated selection of versatile products. Those interested in clean beauty will appreciate our clean beauty guide for sensitive skin, which includes fragrance-free and gentle formulas.

For those exploring Korean skincare, our Korean skincare guide for beginners provides an introduction to K-beauty routines. If you prefer vegan options, our vegan skincare routine guide covers plant-based products that work effectively. Stay updated with the latest trends through our seasonal beauty trends and 2025 makeup trends guides.